3.FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS: 2. RIGHT TO EQUALITY
3.FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS: 2. RIGHT TO EQUALITY
Right to Equality
Articles 14, 15, 16, 17 and 18 of the constitution under part 3 and Articles 38, 39, 39 a, 41 and 46 under part 4 of the constitution.
1. the idea of equality unlike other provisions of the Indian Constitution, say the Principle of Federalism or Trade and Commerce, is an idea that is not just a political principle, but also a moral principle.
2. idea or principle of equality is something that we struggle with and fight with and try to establish in our own daily lives, whether it is our personal lives or our professional lives.
3. what the constitution says about equality in light not just of political debates in the parliament or state legislatures or in the courts, but also as material for you to consider in the application of equality in your daily lives, in fact only then can the real constitutionalism
4. we will be looking at caste, class and gender inequalities, which are the 3 primary fault lines that define Indian Society when viewed from the prism of equality.
5. the so-called equality code under the Indian Constitution can be said to be comprised of two different bunches of provisions; the first is in the Fundamental Rights chapter and the second is in the Directive Principles of State Policy. If we refresh our minds to what we learned last week, the Fundamental Rights are provisions which can be enforced directly by any individual before a court of law. They are in that sense immediately enforceable and justiciable. The Directive Principles of State Policy however are aspirational goals for the government of the day to consider while formulating its programs and policies. They are not immediately enforceable in any court of law. Now the Articles under the Fundamental Rights chapter that we will be concerned with are Articles 14 to 18,
A. Article 14 concerns the Right to Equality defined as the equal protection of laws and equality before the law.
B. Article 15 ensures that the state discriminate on the basis of race, caste, religion, sex or place of birth.
C. Article 17 is a unique provision in the Indian Constitution which deals with the social melody of untouchability, which has plagued the Indian Society for many centuries and unfortunately still continues to play a part in large parts of this country. This Article prohibits the practice of untouchability.
D. Article 18, removes all official titles in India and therefore ensures that we are all equal citizens, there are no princes or maharajas or kings amongst us anymore, we are all equal citizens before the eyes of the law, including the president of India who is nothing more than the first amongst equals.
1. Equality before Law and Equal Protection of Laws
Article 14
says that the State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India.
Article 14 of the constitution. Article 14 notes that the state shall not deny to any person equality before the law or equal protection of the laws within the territory of India.
The first is the expression equality before the law and the second is equal protection of the laws.
FEATURES
This provision confers rights on all persons whether citizens or foreigners.
Moreover, the word ‘person’ includes legal persons, viz, statutory corporations, companies, registered societies or any other type of legal person.
The concept of ‘equality before law’ is of British origin.
The phrase equality before the law means that all citizens of India or all persons shall be subject to the same ordinary law of the land administered by the ordinary law courts. It establishes that there is an absence of privilege in favor of any particular individual no matter who you are, rich or poor, in an official capacity or non-official capacity, whether you are high or low on the social ladder. This therefore, is one of the cornerstones of the Indian equality code. The idea that no matter who you are the same law of the parliament or the state legislature applies to you just like every other citizen of the country.
This means
(a) the absence of any special privileges in favor of any person,
(b) the equal subjection of all persons to the ordinary law of the land administered by ordinary law courts, and
(c) no person (whether rich or poor, high or low, official or non-official) is above the law.
Thus, this is a negative concept
The concept of ‘equal protection of laws’ has been taken from the American Constitution.
The second phrase which is equal protection of the laws means that individuals who are situated in similar circumstances shall be treated equally by the state and those who are situated in different circumstances may be treated differently by the state. Now what does this mean? Now this principle is actually one of the oldest principles of justice that we can trace back to the famous philosopher Aristotle, which is the idea that like must be treated like. Now let me just give you an example of this and to invite you to do a small thought experiment with me.
This connotes:
(a) the equality of treatment under equal circumstances, both in the privileges conferred and liabilities imposed by the laws,
(b) the similar application of the same laws to all persons who are similarly situated, and
(c) the like should be treated alike without any discrimination.
This is a positive concept.
However, both of them aim at establishing equality of legal status, opportunity and justice.
The Supreme Court held that where equals and unequals are treated differently, Article 14 does not apply.
While Article 14 forbids class legislation,
it permits reasonable classification of persons, objects and transactions by the law. But the classification should not be arbitrary, artificial or evasive. Rather, it should be based on an intelligible differential and substantial distinction.
Rule of Law The concept of ‘equality before law’ is an element of the concept of ‘Rule of Law’, propounded by A.V. Dicey, the British jurist. His concept has the following three elements or aspects:
(i) Absence of arbitrary power, that is, no man can be punished except for a breach of law.
(ii) Equality before the law, that is, equal subjection of all citizens (rich or poor, high or low, official or non-official) to the ordinary law of the land administered by the ordinary law courts3 .
(iii) The primacy of the rights of the individual, that is, the constitution is the result of the rights of the individual as defined and enforced by the courts of law rather than the constitution being the source of the individual rights.
The first and the second elements are applicable to the Indian System and not the third one. In the Indian System, the constitution is the source of the individual rights.
The Supreme Court held that the ‘Rule of Law’ as embodied in Article 14 is a ‘basic feature’ of the constitution. Hence, it cannot be destroyed even by an amendment.
Exceptions to Equality The rule of equality before law is not absolute and there are constitutional and other exceptions to it.
These are mentioned below: 1. The President of India and the Governor of States enjoy the following immunities (Article 361): (i) The President or the Governor is not answerable to any court the exercise and performance of the powers and duties of office. (ii) No criminal proceedings shall be instituted or continued aga the President or the Governor in any court during his term office. (iii) No process for the arrest or imprisonment of the President or Governor shall be issued from any court during his term of offic (iv) No civil proceedings against the President or the Governor s be instituted during his term of office in any court in respect of act done by him in his personal capacity, whether before or a he entered upon his office, until the expiration of two months n after notice has been delivered to him.
2. No person shall be liable to any civil or criminal proceedings in any court in respect of the publication in a newspaper (or by radio or television) of a substantially true report of any proceedings of either House of Parliament or either House of the Legislature of a State (Article 361-A).
3. No member of Parliament shall be liable to any proceedings in any court in respect of anything said or any vote given by him in Parliament or any committee thereof (Article 105).
4. No member of the Legislature of a state shall be liable to any proceedings in any court in respect of anything said or any vote given by him in the Legislature or any committee thereof (Article 194).
5. Article 31-C is an exception to Article 14. It provides that the laws made by the state for implementing the Directive Principles contained in clause (b) or clause (c) of Article 39 cannot be challenged on the ground that they are violative of Article 14. The Supreme Court held that “where Article 31-C comes in, Article 14 goes out”.
6. The foreign sovereigns (rulers), ambassadors and diplomats enjoy immunity from criminal and civil proceedings. 7. The UNO and its agencies enjoy the diplomatic immunity.
2. Prohibition of Discrimination on Certain Grounds
Article 15
provides that the State shall not discriminate against any
citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth.
The two crucial words in this provision are ‘discrimination’ and ‘only’.
The word ‘discrimination’ means ‘to make an adverse distinction with regard to’ or ‘to distinguish unfavourably from others’
The use of the word ‘only’ connotes that discrimination on other grounds is not prohibited.
The second provision of Article 15 says that no citizen shall be subjected to any disability, liability, restriction or condition on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth with regard to (a) access to shops, public restaurants, hotels and places of public entertainment; or
(b) the use of wells, tanks, bathing ghats, road and places of public resort maintained wholly or partly by State funds or dedicated to the use of general public
FEATURES
1. This provision prohibits discrimination both by the State and private individuals, while the former provision prohibits discrimination only by the State The second prohibits discrimination by both state and private persons.
2. There are four exceptions to this general rule of non-discrimination:
(a) The state is permitted to make any special provision for women and children. For example, reservation of seats for women in local bodies or provision of free education for children.
(b) The state is permitted to make any special provision for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward classes of citizens or for the scheduled castes and scheduled tribes4. For example, reservation of seats or fee concessions in public educational institutions.
(c) The state is empowered to make any special provision for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward classes of citizens or for the scheduled castes or the scheduled tribes regarding their admission to educational institutions including private educational institutions, whether aided or unaided by the state, except the minority educational institutions.
(d) The state is empowered to make any special provision for the advancement of any economically weaker sections of citizens.
Further, the state is allowed to make a provision for the
reservation of upto 10% of seats for such sections in admission
to educational institutions including private educational
institutions, whether aided or unaided by the state, except the
minority educational institutions. This reservation of upto 10%
would be in addition to the existing reservations. For this
purpose, the economically weaker sections would be notified by
the state from time to time on the basis of family income and
other indicators of economic disadvantage.
Reservation for OBCs in Educational Institutions
The above exception(c) was added by the 93rd Amendment Act of 2005. In order to give effect to this provision, the Centre enacted the Central Educational Institutions (Reservation in Admission) Act, 2006, providing a quota of 27% for candidates belonging to the Other Backward Classes (OBCs) in all central higher educational institutions including the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) and the Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs)
. In April 2008, the Supreme Court upheld the validity of both, the Amendment Act and the OBC Quota Act. But, the Court directed the central government to exclude the ‘creamy layer’ (advanced sections) among the OBCs while implementing the law
The children of the following different categories of people belong to ‘creamy layer’ among OBCs and thus will not get the quota benefit :
1. Persons holding constitutional posts like President, Vice-
President, Judges of SC and HCs, Chairman and Members of
UPSC and SPSCs, CEC, CAG and so on.
2. Group ‘A’ / Class I and Group ‘B’ / Class II Officers of the All
India, Central and State Services; and Employees holding
equivalent posts in PSUs, Banks, Insurance Organisations,
Universities etc., and also in private employment.
3. Persons who are in the rank of colonel and above in the Army
and equivalent posts in the Navy, the Air Force and the
Paramilitary Forces.
4. Professionals like doctors, lawyers, engineers, artists, authors,
consultants and so on.
5. Persons engaged in trade, business and industry.
6. People holding agricultural land above a certain limit and vacant
land or buildings in urban areas.
7. Persons having gross annual income of more than ₹8 lakh or
possessing wealth above the exemption limit. In 1993, when the
“creamy layer” ceiling was introduced, it was ₹1 lakh. It was
subsequently revised to ₹2.5 lakh in 2004, ₹4.5 lakh in 2008, ₹6
lakh in 2013 and ₹8 lakh in 2017.
Reservation for EWSs in Educational Institutions
The above exception (d) was added by the 103rd Amendment Act of 2019. In order to give effect to this provision, the central government issued an order (in 2019) providing 10% reservation to the Economically Weaker Sections (EWSs) in admission to educational institutions. The benefit of this reservation can be availed by the persons belonging to EWSs who are not covered under any of the existing schemes of reservations for SCs, STs and OBCs.
The eligibility criteria laid down in this regard is as follows:
1. Persons whose family has gross annual income below ₹8 lakh are to be identified as EWSs for the benefit of reservation. The income would include income from all sources i.e., salary, agriculture, business, profession etc. and it would be income for the financial year prior to the year of application.
2. Persons whose family owns or possesses any one of the following assets are to be excluded from being identified as EWSs, irrespective of the family income:
(a) 5 acres of Agricultural land and above.
(b) Residential flat of 1000 sq.ft. and above.
(c) Residential plot of 100 sq.yards and above in notified municipalities.
(d) Residential plot of 200 sq.yards and above in areas other than the notified municipalities.
3. The property held by a family in different locations or different places / cities would be clubbed while applying the land or property holding test to determine EWS status.
4. Family for this purpose would include the person who seeks benefit of reservation, his/her parents and siblings below the age of 18 years as also his/ her spouse and children below the ageof 18 years.
3. Equality of Opportunity in Public Employment
Article 16
provides for equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters of employment or appointment to any office under the State. No citizen can be discriminated against or be ineligible for any employment or office under the State on grounds of only religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth or residence.
There are four exceptions to this general rule of equality of
opportunity in public employment:
(a) Parliament can prescribe residence as a condition for certain employment or appointment in a state or union territory or local authority or other authority. As the Public Employment (Requirement as to Residence) Act of 1957 expired in 1974, there is no such provision for any state except Andhra Pradesh and Telangana
(b) The State can provide for reservation of appointments or posts in favour of any backward class that is not adequately represented in the state services.
(c) A law can provide that the incumbent of an office related to religious or denominational institution or a member of its governing body should belong to the particular religion or denomination.
(d) The state is permitted to make a provision for the reservation of upto 10% of appointments or posts in favour of any economically weaker sections of citizens. This reservation of upto 10% would be in addition to the existing reservation. For this purpose, the economically weaker sections would be notified by the state from time to time on the basis of family income and other indicators of economic disadvantage.
Mandal Commission and Aftermath
In 1979, the Morarji Desai Government appointed the Second Backward Classes Commission under the chairmanship of B.P. Mandal, a Member of Parliament, in terms of Article 340 of the Constitution to investigate the conditions of the socially and educationally backward classes and suggest measures for their advancement.
The commission submitted its report in 1980 and identified as many as 3743 castes as socially and educationally backward classes. They constitute nearly 52% component of the population, excluding the scheduled castes (SCs) and the scheduled tribes (STs).
The commission recommended for reservation of 27% government jobs for the Other Backward Classes (OBCs) so that the total reservation for all ((SCs, STs and OBCs) amounts to 50%.7
It was after ten years in 1990 that the V.P. Singh Government declared
reservation of 27% government jobs for the OBCs.
Again in 1991, the Narasimha Rao Government introduced two changes: (a) preference to the poorer sections among the OBCs in the 27% quota, i.e., adoption of the economic criteria in granting reservation, and (b) reservation of another 10% of jobs for poorer (economically backward) sections of higher castes who are not covered by any existing schemes of reservation.
In the famous Mandal case (1992), the scope and extent of Article
16(4), which provides for reservation of jobs in favour of backward classes, has been examined thoroughly by the Supreme Court.
Though the Court has rejected the additional reservation of 10% for
poorer sections of higher castes,
it upheld the constitutional validity of 27% reservation for the OBCs with certain conditions, viz,
(a) The advanced sections among the OBCs (the creamy layer) should be excluded from the list of beneficiaries of reservation.
(b) No reservation in promotions; reservation should be confined to initial appointments only. Any existing reservation in promotions can continue for five years only (i.e., upto 1997).
(c) The total reserved quota should not exceed 50% except in some extraordinary situations. This rule should be applied every year.
(d) The ‘carry forward rule’ in case of unfilled (backlog) vacancies is valid. But it should not violate 50% rule.
(e) A permanent statutory body should be established to examine complaints of over-inclusion and under-inclusion in the list of OBCs.
With regard to the above rulings of the Supreme Court, the government has taken the following actions:
(a) Ram Nandan Committee was appointed to identify the creamy layer among the OBCs. It submitted its report in 1993, which was accepted.
(b) National Commission for Backward Classes was established in 1993 by an act of Parliament. Its mandate was to examine the complaints of under-inclusion, over-inclusion or non-inclusion of any class of citizens in the list of backward classes for the purpose of job reservation. Later, the 102nd Amendment Act of 2018 conferred a constitutional status on the commission and also enlarged its functions. For this purpose, the amendment inserted a new Article 338-B in the constitution.
Reservation in Promotions, the
A. 77th Amendment Act was enacted in 1995. It added a new provision in Article 16 that empowers the State to provide for reservation in promotions of any services under theState in favour of the SCs and STs that are not adequatelyrepresented in the state services.
B. 85th Amendment
Act of 2001 provides for ‘consequential seniority’ in the case of promotion by virtue of rule of reservation for the government servants belonging to the SCs and STs with retrospective effect from June 1995.
NULLYFYING 50% CEILING
A, 81st Amendment Act of 2000. It added another new provision in Article 16 that empowers the State to consider the unfilled reserved vacancies of a year as a separate class of vacancies to be filled up in any succeeding year or years. Such class of vacancies are not to be combined with the vacancies of the year in which they are being filled up to determine the ceiling of 50%reservation on total number of vacancies of that year. In brief, it ends the 50% ceiling on reservation in backlog vacancies.
B. 76th Amendment Act of 1994 has placed the Tamil Nadu Reservations Act9 of 1994 in the Ninth Schedule to protect it from judicial review as it provided for 69 per cent of reservation, far exceeding the 50 per cent ceiling. Reservation for EWSs in Public Employment
EWS RESERVATION
103rd Amendment Act of 2019. In order to give effect to this provision, the central government issued an order (in 2019) providing 10% reservation to the Economically Weaker Sections (EWSs) in civil posts and services in the Government of India. The benefit of this reservation can be a vailedby the persons belonging to EWSs who are not covered under any of the existing schemes of reservation for SCs, STs and OBCs. The eligibility criteria laid down in this regard has already been explained under Article 15.
EXCEPTION FROM RESERVATION
Further, the scientific and technical posts which satisfy all the following conditions can be exempted from the purview of this reservation:
(i) The posts should be in grades above the lower grade in Group A of the service concerned.
(ii) They should be classified as “scientific or technical” in terms of Cabinet Secretariat Order (1961), according to which scientific and technical posts for which qualifications in the natural sciences or exact sciences or applied sciences or in technology are prescribed and the incumbents of which have to use that knowledge in the discharge of their duties.
(iii) The posts should be for conducting research or for organizing,guiding and directing research.
Abolition of Untouchability
Article 17 abolishes ‘untouchability’ and forbids its practice in any form. The enforcement of any disability arising out of untouchability shall be an offence punishable in accordance with law.
In 1976, the Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955 has been comprehensively amended and renamed as the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 to enlarge the scope and make penal provisions more stringent. The act defines civil right as any right accruing to a person by reason of the abolition of untouchability by Article 17 of the Constitution.
The term ‘untouchability’ has not been defined either in the Constitution or in the Act. However, the Mysore High Court held that the subject matter of Article 17 is not untouchability in its literal or grammatical sense but the ‘practice as it had developed historically in the country’. It refers to the social disabilities imposed on certain classes of persons by reason of their birth in certain castes. Hence, it does not cover social boycott of a few individuals or their exclusion from religious services, etc.
The Supreme Court held that the right under Article 17 is available against private individuals and it is the constitutional obligation of the State to take necessary action to ensure that this right is not violated.
Abolition of Titles
Article 18 abolishes titles and makes four provisions in that regard:
(a) It prohibits the state from conferring any title (except a military or academic distinction) on any body, whether a citizen or a foreigner.
(b) It prohibits a citizen of India from accepting any title from any foreign state.
(c) A foreigner holding any office of profit or trust under the state cannot accept any title from any foreign state without the consent of the president.
(d) No citizen or foreigner holding any office of profit or trust under the State is to accept any present, emolument or office from or under any foreign State without the consent of the president.
From the above, it is clear that the hereditary titles of nobility like Maharaja, Raj Bahadur, Rai Bahadur, Rai Saheb, Dewan Bahadur, etc, which were conferred by colonial States are banned by Article 18 as these are against the principle of equal status of all.
In 1996 , the Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of the National Awards–Bharat Ratna, Padma Vibhushan, Padma Bhushan and Padma Sri. It ruled that these awards do not amount to ‘titles’ within the meaning of Article 18 that prohibits only hereditary titles of nobility. Therefore, they are not violative of Article 18 as thetheory of equality does not mandate that merit should not berecognised. However, it also ruled that they should not be used assuffixes or prefixes to the names of awardees. Otherwise, they shouldforfeit the awards.
These National Awards were instituted in 1954. The Janata Party government headed by Morarji Desai discontinued them in 1977. But they were again revived in 1980 by the Indira Gandhi government.
Comments
Post a Comment