2. FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS 1.SIGNIFICANCE, FEATURES, TYPES, LIMITATIONS AND THE STATE

                                                         Fundamental Rights

FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS 1.SIGNIFICANCE, FEATURES, TYPES, LIMITATIONS AND THE STATE


WHAT IS RIGHT

(1)   First to have arrived may mean the right to do something. For example, you might say I have the right to speak, or the right to express myself. This kind of a right or right to do some is commonly understood as a privilege, or a liberty. When I say I have the rights to speak, I often mean that you do not have the right to stop me. So this kind of right, the rights to do something is, is one rather large species of rights claims that we commonly use in our everyday language. 


(2) The second sense in which we might use a right is to is to say that I have a right meaning that someone else has to do things for me. This kind of right is a right that imposes obligations on us. It allows me to clean off, off others. For example, I might say that I have the right to be treated equally. When we ask, what does that mean? What does it mean? What does it mean to say that you have the right to be treated equally? The sense that we would give to that rights claim is to say that you have the obligation, those on to whom my right flies have the obligation to treat me equally with others. So, this is a very different sense, from the first sense in which we use rights as a privilege or liberty.

(3) The thirds, in which we, we might say that I have a right is to have a right to do some, that changes another person's legal. This kind of right the power to change someone else's legal position is often civil rights. It is not constitutional fundamental right. And let me just use a simple example. I have a contract, for example, to buy a car. If I enter into such a contract with a potential seller of a car, by closing that contract, I have the right to have the other person and over the car, I have changed their legal position as the owner of the car and I become the owner, I am using a very simple example. There could be far more complicated examples of the right to change and others the capacity of a rights holder to change another person's legal position.

(4) The fourth way in which we use rights schemes is often to say that by saying that I have a right, I am free from a liability or legal duty to some. For example, a right to remain silent in a criminal investigation. When I have a right to remain silent, no matter what legal powers and authority a criminal investigator might exercise, my rights to remain silent, gives me an immunity to whatever statutory or legal power the criminal investigator is using. It is a sort of a right is in an immunity sense is like a bubble. It is a bubble that prevents interference of others with my life. So, whenever we use the word, right, we might be using it in any one of these four senses discussed here.


what do rights do for the persons who have rights?  

1. EMPOWERING EFFECT---Often times, whenever one says that you have a right, it means that the, the person has an autonomy, the will or the choice to do something or not to do something. So, it empowers the rights holder to either do or not do something.


2. ELEVATION OF RIGHTS--The second important element to having the right is that it elevates some of the rights holders

interests, for example, education and health care and pleases it about the common free. This

ability that what rights in this sense is a power shifting device. It takes my will, my choice, my

interests and elevates these individual choices of interests and elevates them above the ordinary

social interests that might otherwise override.


3. PUTTING OBLIGATION--One effect effect of the right is the presence of a right imposes obligations on other actors, whether the society or the state to ensure that no one is left hungry. This kind of power shifting effect is what rights have and rights the form and function of rights is to shift power, the power balance between the rights holder on the one hand and society at large. This is the effect that that rights have. And as we explore this question, in greater detail in the Constitution.



TYPES OF RIGHTS


Natural rights seem to be grounded in the moral power, the dignity and the capacity inherent in every human being. The person is the foundation of natural rights. . There is something specific to the nature of the human species to which we attach rights natural rights emerges from being human, We normally speak in the language of

the basic entitles to Life, Liberty and Property. These are the natural rights that have been spoken

about in the intellectual traditions of talking about rights for, for centuries.  These 3 elements as being inherent and emerging from the dignity of human beings themselves


 Are human rights natural rights?  Some human rights

are moral rights natural, seen as moral rights or natural rights while some human rights are seen as legal. But that body of human rights are usually quite wide, they have both negative and positive rights, sometimes requiring states to be affirmative acts, while at other times, requiring states to just do to carry out some to prevent interference in our personal lives. Often, when we speak about human rights, we speak in terms of them being universal to all human beings, not contingent on the nation state that we live in, or the particular political constitution under which we live. We also see human rights as being inalienable, nobody can take away your human rights, and as being fundamental, overriding all other rights, all other legal and political rights that you might claim, and binding on all actors. This language of human rights is very important to understand and appreciate. And I sense that many of us grew up being exposed to the language of human rights, but not being able to precisely locate what human rights might be.

LEGAL RIGHTS

 legal rights are created by the state, but they can also be erased by the state, so legislation can take away legal rights. So, no matter what the legislation is, we need continue to insist that we have human rights, contrary to legislation, we may also continue to insist that we have natural rights, contrary to legislation. But legal rights are always focused on the question, what has the state created,  

   CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS      

 The fourth category of rights with which I conclude my typology of Rights, is to talk in is to explore what it means to call something a constitution. Constitutional rights are qualitatively different from and superior to legal rights. So, let us assume for a moment we discussed some legal rights merging from the Citizenship Act of 1955. These legal rights are created by Parliament, and applicable to all those residents in India citizens or not or those who seek to become citizens of Indian. Constitutional rights are superior to legal rights in this important way. If any legal statute or decision, often an administrative body, or sometimes even a full court violates constitutional rights, then those, those decisions can be declared invalid. 

                      So, constitutional rights sit above the ordinary legal rights, natural rights and human rights of others, they are specially protected by the Constitution. But when we say they enjoy constitutional protection, it does not mean that they are immutable. It does not mean that they can never be changed, it only means that they can be changed by amending the Constitution, which is far more difficult than just changing a statue. So, let me bring this together before we, move away from the Typology of Rights, we have discussed 4 kinds of rights. So, every time you use, we use rights language in a common sense and common conversation, we will do well to ask the question, what rights are you claiming? Are you claiming natural rights, human rights, legal rights or constitutional rights? By bringing this kind of clarity to our everyday conversation, we make considerable progress in understanding the nature of constitutional fundamental rights


Universal Declaration of Human Rights,  

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which was created in 1948, by the several nations that came together, and we are talking about 150 nations plus came together to create the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and international government.  .

    It begins with the broad proposition that all human beings are born free, and equal in dignity and rights. Notice the emphasis on human beings, being born with dignity and rights. And this is not conferred by states, or conferred by God, but natural in its origin, just by virtue of hard work. 

It continues to assure us that everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth in this declaration, without distinction, meaning without discrimination. So, all human beings without discrimination, what rights do we have, we have the common rights of life, liberty and security of person, what we what we discussed, when we spoke about natural rights, these are declared as core human rights.

  But further every month, as a member of society has a right to Social Security, and rights to economic, social, and cultural rights, which are indispensable to one's dignity, and development of one's personality. This kind of language that you find in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, brings together different kinds of  rights of they are all human rights, but their rights that are sometimes about civil and political goals, and at other times about economic, social and cultural goals


 two different treaties, international treaties, came to be signed, called the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights in 1976, and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 1976 that build on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. So these rights, put together, comprise a corpus of international human rights that operate as a broad framework to guide rights thinking across the globe.

These rights are not dependent on your constitutional guarantees, they go beyond them. And we may always take reference to these International Covenants and the Universal Declaration.


Often, while talking about international human rights, we talk about 3 kinds of rights, or 3 generations of international human rights. And let me just refer to them. Some when we talk when we speak in the language of generations, we think of this in terms of a chronology. But we need to do that we can think of these mainly as 3 different types of rights. The 3 broad types of rights are Civil and Political rights, Economic, Social, and Cultural rights, and Collective rights or Group rights, Solidarity rights. Paying attention to these types of rights is very useful when we begin our discussion of the Indian Constitution.


RIGHTS IN OUR CONSTITUTION


1. In the Indian Constitution, rights and, and Directive Principles, Part 3, and Part 4 of the Constitution make up the corpus of human or natural rights that are crystallized into constitutional rights in the Constitution.

2.  In the Indian Constitution, a decision was made to put political and civil rights broadly into Part 3 of the Constitution and call them fundamental rights. And to put socio economic and some cultural rights broadly in Part 4 of the Constitution, and devise a different mechanism for the interpretation and enforce. 

3. There are other constitutional rights, which are not in Part 3, or in Part 4. And these might, and we have identified some of them on the slide for you, Articles 265, which deals with no, which is crystallizes the broad principle, that there can be new taxation, without representation. Article 308, which now contains the remnants of a right to property, and something that we discussed earlier in this course, the Right to Vote, which is in Article 326.



The  Fundamental  Rights  are  enshrined  in  Part  III  of  the Constitution from Articles 12 to 35. In this regard, the framers of the Constitution derived inspiration from the Constitution of


SIGNIFICANCR OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS

1.Inspired by the USA's  Bill of Rights.


2.Part III of the Constitution is rightly described as the Magna Carta of India.


3. It contains a very long and comprehensive list of 'justiciable’ Fundamental  Rights.  In  fact,  the  Fundamental  Rights  in  our Constitution are more elaborate than those found in the Constitution of any other country in the world, including the USA.


4. The Fundamental Rights are guaranteed by the Constitution to all persons without any discrimination. They uphold the equality of all individuals, the dignity of the individual, the larger public interest and unity of the nation.


5. The Fundamental Rights are meant for promoting the ideal of political  democracy.  They  prevent  

the  establishment  of  an authoritarian and despotic rule in the country. 



6. Protect the  liberties and freedoms of the people against the invasion by the State. They operate as limitations on the tyranny of the executive and arbitrary laws of the legislature. In short, they aim at establishing 'a government of laws and not of men’.


WHY FUNDAMENTAL

1.The  Fundamental  Rights  are  named  so  because  they  are guaranteed  and  protected  by  the  Constitution,  which  is  the fundamental law of the land. 


2. They are 'fundamental’ also in the sense that they are most essential for the all-round development (material, intellectual, moral and spiritual) of the individuals.


3. Article 13 is a very powerful art, because it instructs all those who take and exercise legal public authority, that if such public authority is exercised in a manner that offends rights, it would be invalid and have no legal effect


4. Article 32, which, which gives the Supreme Court and article 226, gives the High Courts the power to enforce these rights and to declare that state action is invalid


5. w let us put the 3 articles together. Article 13 tells all actors, state actors cannot make any law that that bridges or takes away fundamental rights. Article 12, clarifies that this is primarily applicable to state actors, meaning the legislature, the executive, and other local authorities and the judiciary, other public authorities. Finally, Article 32 gives the power to the Supreme Court to enforce these rights. Taken together fundamental constitutional rights, we see a very strong protection.


HOW MANY FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS

Originally, the Constitution provided for seven Fundamental Rights viz,

1. Right to equality (Articles 14-18)

2. Right to freedom (Articles 19-22)

3. Right against exploitation (Articles 23-24)

4. Right to freedom of religion (Articles 25-28)

5. Cultural and educational rights (Articles 29-30)

6. Right to property (Article 31)

7. Right to constitutional remedies (Article 32)


However,  the  right  to  property  was  deleted  from  the  list  of Fundamental Rights by the 

44th Amendment Act, 1978. It is made a legal right under Article 300-A in Part XII of the 

Constitution. So at present, there are only six Fundamental Rights.



FEATURES OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS

The  Fundamental  Rights  guaranteed  by  the  Constitution  are characterized by the following:

1. Some of them are available only to the citizens while others are available to all persons 

whether citizens, foreigners or legal persons like corporations or companies.


2. They are not absolute but qualified. The state can impose reasonable  restrictions  on  them.  

However,  whether  such restrictions are reasonable or not is to be decided by the courts. Thus, 

they strike a balance between the rights of the individual and those of the society as a whole, 

between individual liberty and social control.


3. All of them are available against the arbitrary action of the state. However, some of them are 

also available against the action of private individuals.


4. Some of them are negative in character, that is, place limitations on the authority of the 

State, while others are positive in nature, conferring certain privileges on the persons.


5. They are justiciable, allowing persons to move the courts for their enforcement, if and when 

they are violated. They are defended and guaranteed by the Supreme Court. Hence, the aggrieved person can directly go to the Supreme Court, not necessarily by way of appeal against the judgement of the high courts.


6. They are not sacrosanct or permanent. The Parliament can curtail or repeal them but only by a 

constitutional amendment act and not by an ordinary act. Moreover, this can be done without 

affecting  the  'basic  structure’  of  the  Constitution.  (The amenability  of  fundamental  

rights  is  explained  in  detail  in Chapter 11).

7. They can be suspended 

(a) during the operation of a National Emergency except the rights guaranteed by Articles 20 and 21.

 (b) Further,  the  six  rights  guaranteed  by  Article  19  can  be suspended  only when emergency is declared on the grounds of war or external aggression (i.e., external emergency) and not on the ground of armed rebellion (i.e., internal emergency). 

LIMITATIONS ON APPLICATION OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS 

ARTICLE 31 A TO ARTICLE 35

8. Their scope of operation is limited by Article 31A (saving of laws providing for acquisition of 

estates, etc.), Article 31B (validation of certain acts and regulations included in the 9th 

Schedule) and Article 31C (saving of laws giving effect to certain directive principles).


11. Their application to the members of armed forces, para-military forces,  police  forces,  

intelligence  agencies  and  analogous services can be restricted or abrogated by the Parliament 

(Article 33).


11. Their application can be restricted while martial law is in force in any  area.  Martial  law  

means  'military  rule’  imposed  under abnormal  circumstances  to  restore  order  (Article  34). 

 It  is different from the imposition of national emergency.


12. Most of them are directly enforceable (self-executory) while a few of them can be enforced on 

the basis of a law made for giving effect to them. Such a law can be made only by the Parliament  

and  not  by  state  legislatures  so  that  uniformity throughout the country is maintained 

(Article 35).


ARTICLE 12---DEFINITION OF STATE

The term 'State’ has been used in different provisions concerning the fundamental rights. Hence, 

Article 12 has defined the term for the purposes of Part III. According to it, the State includes 

the following:

(a) Government and Parliament of India, that is, executive and legislative organs of the Union 

government.

(b) Government and legislature of states, that is, executive and legislative organs of state 

government.

(c) All local authorities, that is, municipalities, panchayats, district boards, improvement 

trusts, etc.

(d) All other authorities, that is, statutory or non-statutory authorities like LIC, ONGC, SAIL, 

etc.

Thus, State has been defined in a wider sense so as to include all its agencies. It is the actions 

of these agencies that can be challenged in the courts as violating the Fundamental Rights.

According to the Supreme Court, even a private body or an agency working as an instrument of the 

State falls within the meaning of the 'State’ under Article 12.


Article 13 

                 declares that all laws that are inconsistent with or in derogation of any of the fundamental rights shall be void. 

                                  In other words, it expressively provides for the doctrine of judicial review. This power has been conferred on the Supreme Court (Article 32) and the high courts (Article 226) that can declare a law unconstitutional and invalid on the ground of contravention of any of the Fundamental Rights. 

The term ‘law’ in Article 13 has been given a wide connotation so as to include the following:

 (a) Permanent laws enacted by the Parliament or the state legislatures;

 (b) Temporary laws like ordinances issued by the president or the state governors;

 (c) Statutory instruments in the nature of delegated legislation (executive legislation) like order, bye-law, rule, regulation or notification; and

 (d) Non-legislative sources of law, that is, custom or usage having the force of law. 

                          Thus, not only a legislation but any of the above can be challenged in the courts as violating a Fundamental Right and hence, can be declared as void.

 Further, Article 13 declares that a constitutional amendment is not a law and hence cannot be challenged. 

However, the Supreme Court held in the Kesavananda Bharati case2 (1973) that a Constitutional amendment can be challenged on the ground that it violates a fundamental right that forms a part of the ‘basic structure’ of the Constitution and hence, can be declared as void.



                                                  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2. Union and its Territory

THE PREAMBLE BY NLU

3.FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS: 2. RIGHT TO EQUALITY