4. FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS: 3 RIGHT TO FREEDOM
4. FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS: 3 RIGHT TO FREEDOM
ARTICLE 19
RIGHT TO FREEDOM
1. Protection of Six Rights
Article 19 guarantees to all citizens the six rights. These are:
(i) Right to freedom of speech and expression.
(ii) Right to assemble peaceably and without arms.
(iii) Right to form associations or unions or co-operative societies.¹Oᵃ
(iv) Right to move freely throughout the territory of India.
(v) Right to reside and settle in any part of the territory of India.
(vi) Right to practice any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business.
Originally, Article 19 contained seven rights. But, the right to acquire, hold and dispose of property was deleted by the 44th Amendment Act of 1978.
These six rights are protected against only state action and not private individuals. Moreover, these rights are available only to the citizens and to shareholders of a company but not to foreigners or legal persons like companies or corporations, etc.
The State can impose 'reasonable’ restrictions on the enjoyment of these six rights only on the grounds mentioned in the Article 19 itself and not on any other grounds.
Freedom of Speech and Expression
It implies that every citizen has the right to express his views, opinions, belief and convictions freely by word of mouth, writing, printing, picturing or in any other manner. The Supreme Court held that the freedom of speech and expression includes the following:
(a) Right to propagate one’s views as well as views of others.
(b) Freedom of the press.
(c) Freedom of commercial advertisements.
(d) Right against tapping of telephonic conversation.
(e) Right to telecast, that is, government has no monopoly on electronic media.
(f) Right against bundh called by a political party or organisation.
(g) Right to know about government activities.
(h) Freedom of silence.
(i) Right against imposition of pre-censorship on a newspaper.
(j) Right to demonstration or picketing but not right to strike.
The State can impose Reasonable Restrictions on the exercise of the freedom of speech and expression on the grounds of
. sovereignty and integrity of India,
. security of the state,
friendly relations with foreign states,
public order,
decency or morality,
contempt of court,
defamation, and
incitement to an offence.
Freedom of Assembly
Every citizen has the right to assemble peaceably and without arms. It includes the right to hold
public meetings, demonstrations and take out processions.
LIMITATIONS
1. This freedom can be exercised only on public land and the assembly must be peaceful and unarmed.
2. This provision does not protect violent, disorderly, riotous assemblies, or one that causes breach of public peace or one that involves arms.
3. This right does not include the right to strike.
The State can impose Reasonable Restrictions on the exercise of right of assembly on two grounds,
namely,
sovereignty and integrity of India and
public order including the maintenance of traffic in the area concerned.
Under Section 144 of Criminal Procedure Code (1973), a magistrate can restrain an assembly, meeting or procession if there is a risk of obstruction, annoyance or danger to human life, health or safety or a disturbance of the public tranquility or a riot or any affray.
Under Section 141 of the Indian Penal Code, as assembly of five or more persons becomes unlawful if the object is
(a) to resist the execution of any law or legal process;
(b) to forcibly occupy the property of some person;
(c) to commit any mischief or criminal trespass;
(d) to force some person to do an illegal act; and
(e) to threaten the government or its officials on exercising lawful powers.
UAPA
Freedom of Association
All citizens have the right to form associations or unions or co- operative societies¹Oᵇ. It includes the right to form political parties, companies, partnership firms, societies, clubs, organizations, trade unions or any body of persons. It not only includes the right to start an association or union but also to continue with the association or union as such.
Further, it covers the negative right of not to form or join an association or union.
Reasonable Restrictions can be imposed on the exercise of this right by the State on the grounds of
sovereignty and integrity of India,
public order and morality.
Subject to these restrictions, the
citizens have complete liberty to form associations or unions for pursuing lawful objectives and purposes.
However, the right to obtain recognition of the association is not a fundamental right.
The Supreme Court held that the trade unions have no guaranteed right to effective bargaining or right to strike or right to declare a lock- out. The right to strike can be controlled by an appropriate industrial law.
Freedom of Movement
This freedom entitles every citizen to move freely throughout the territory of the country. He can
move freely from one state to another or from one place to another within a state.
The grounds of imposing Reasonable Restrictions on this freedom are two, namely,
the interests of general public and
protection of interests of any scheduled tribe.
The entry of outsiders in tribal areas is restricted to protect the distinctive culture, language, customs and manners of scheduled tribes and to safeguard their traditional vocation and properties against exploitation.The Supreme Court held that the freedom of movement of prostitutes can be restricted on the ground of public health and in the interest of public morals.
The Bombay High Court validated the restrictions on the movement of persons affected by AIDS.
The freedom of movement has two dimensions, viz, internal (right to move inside the country) and
external (right to move out of the country and right to come back to the country). Article 19
protects only the first dimension.
The second dimension is dealt by Article 21 (right to life and personal liberty).
Freedom of Residence
Every citizen has the right to reside and settle in any part of the territory of the country. This right has two parts:
(a) the right to reside in any part of the country, which means to stay at any place temporarily, and
(b) the right to settle in any part of the country, which means to set up a home or domicile at any place permanently.
This right is intended to remove internal barriers within the country or between any of its parts. This promotes nationalism and avoids narrow mindedness.
The State can impose Reasonable Restrictions on the exercise of this right on two grounds, namely,
the interest of general public and the protection of interests of any scheduled tribes.
The right of outsiders to reside and settle in tribal areas is restricted to protect the distinctive culture, language, customs and manners of scheduled tribes and to safeguard their traditional vocation and properties against exploitation. In many parts of the country, the tribals have been permitted to regulate their property rights in accordance with their customary rules and laws.
The Supreme Court held that certain areas can be banned for certain kinds of persons like prostitutes and habitual offenders.
From the above, it is clear that the right to residence and the right to movement are overlapping to some extent. Both are complementary to each other.
Freedom of Profession, etc.
All citizens are given the right to practise any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business. This right is very wide as it covers all the means of earning one’s livelihood.
The State can impose Reasonable Restrictions on the exercise of this right in the interest of the
general public.
Further, the State is empowered to:
(a) prescribe professional or technical qualifications necessary for practising any profession or
carrying on any occupation, trade or business; and
(b) carry on by itself any trade, business, industry or service whether to the exclusion (complete
or partial) of citizens or otherwise.
Thus, no objection can be made when the State carries on a trade, business, industry or service
either as a monopoly (complete or partial) to the exclusion of citizens (all or some only) or in
competition with any citizen. The State is not required to justify its monopoly.
This right does not include the right to carry on a profession or business or trade or occupation that is immoral (trafficking in women or children) or dangerous (harmful drugs or explosives, etc,). The State can absolutely prohibit these or regulate them through licencing.
Protection in Respect of Conviction for Offences
Article 2O
grants protection against arbitrary and excessive punishment to an accused
person, whether citizen or foreigner or legal person like a company or a corporation. It contains
three provisions in that direction:
(a) No ex-post-facto law: No person shall be (i) convicted of any offence except for violation of a
law in force at the time of the
commission of the act, nor (ii) subjected to a penalty greater than that prescribed by the law in
force at the time of the commission of the act.
(b) No double jeopardy: No person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence
more than once.
(c) No self-incrimination: No person accused of any offence shall be compelled to be a witness
against himself.
An ex-post-facto law is one that imposes penalties retrospectively (retroactively), that is, upon
acts already done or which increases the penalties for such acts. The enactment of such a law is
prohibited by the first provision of Article 2O. However, this limitation is imposed only on
criminal laws and not on civil laws or tax laws. In other words, a civil liability or a tax can be
imposed retrospectively. Further, this provision prohibits only conviction or sentence under an
ex-post-facto criminal law and not the trial thereof. Finally, the protection (immunity) under this
provision cannot be claimed in case of preventive detention or demanding security from a person.
The protection against double jeopardy is available only in
proceedings before a court of law or a judicial tribunal. In other words, it is not available in
proceedings before departmental or administrative authorities as they are not of judicial nature.
The protection against self-incrimination extends to both oral evidence and documentary
evidence. However, it does not extend to
(i) compulsory production of material objects, (ii) compulsion to give thumb impression, specimen
signature, blood specimens, and (iii) compulsory exhibition of the body. Further, it extends only
to criminal proceedings and not to civil proceedings or proceedings which are not of criminal
nature.
3. Protection of Life and Personal Liberty
Article 21 declares that no person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except
according to procedure established by law. This right is available to both citizens and
non-citizens.
In the famous Gopalan case¹¹ (195O), the Supreme Court has taken a narrow interpretation of the
Article 21. It held that the protection under Article 21 is available only against arbitrary
executive action and not from arbitrary legislative action. This means that the State can deprive
the right to life and personal liberty of a person based on a law. This is because of the
expression 'procedure established by law’ in Article 21, which is different from the expression
'due process of law’ contained in the American Constitution. Hence, the validity of a law that has
prescribed a procedure cannot be questioned on the ground that the law is unreasonable, unfair or
unjust. Secondly, the Supreme Court held that the 'personal liberty’ means only liberty relating to
the person or body of the individual. But, in Menaka case¹² (1978), the Supreme Court overruled its
judgement in the Gopalan case by taking a wider interpretation of the Article 21. Therefore, it
ruled that the right to life and personal liberty of a person can be deprived by a law provided the
procedure prescribed by that law is reasonable, fair and just. In other words, it has introduced
the American expression 'due process of law’. In effect, the protection under Article 21 should
be available not only against arbitrary executive action but also against arbitrary
legislative action. Further, the court held that the 'right to life’ as embodied in Article 21 is
not merely confined to animal existence or survival but it includes within its ambit the right to
live with human dignity and all those aspects of life which go to make a man’s life meaningful,
complete and worth living. It also ruled that the expression 'Personal Liberty’ in Article 21 is of
the widest amplitude and it covers a variety of rights that go to constitute the personal liberties
of a man.
The Supreme Court has reaffirmed its judgement in the Menaka case in the subsequent cases. It has
declared the following rights as part of Article 21:
(1) Right to live with human dignity.
(2) Right to decent environment including pollution free water and air and protection against
hazardous industries.
(3) Right to livelihood.
(4) Right to privacy.
(5) Right to shelter.
(6) Right to health.
(7) Right to free education up to 14 years of age.
(8) Right to free legal aid.
(9) Right against solitary confinement. (1O) Right to speedy trial.
(11) Right against handcuffing.
(12) Right against inhuman treatment.
(13) Right against delayed execution.
(14) Right to travel abroad.
(15) Right against bonded labour.
(16) Right against custodial harassment.
(17) Right to emergency medical aid.
(18) Right to timely medical treatment in government hospital.
(19) Right not to be driven out of a state. (2O) Right to fair trial.
(21) Right of prisoner to have necessities of life.
(22) Right of women to be treated with decency and dignity.
(23) Right against public hanging.
(24) Right to road in hilly areas.
(25) Right to information.
(26) Right to reputation.
(27) Right of appeal from a judgement of conviction
(28) Right to family pension
(29) Right to social and economic justice and empowerment (3O) Right against bar fetters
(31) Right to appropriate life insurance policy
(32) Right to sleep
(33) Right to freedom from noise pollution
(34) Right to sustainable development
(35) Right to opportunity.
4. Right to Education
Article 21 A declares that the State shall provide free and compulsory education to all children of
the age of six to fourteen years in such a manner as the State may determine. Thus, this provision
makes only elementary education a Fundamental Right and not higher or professional
education.
This provision was added by the 86th Constitutional Amendment Act of 2OO2. This amendment is a
major milestone in the country’s aim to achieve 'Education for All’. The government described this
step as 'the dawn of the second revolution in the chapter of citizens’ rights’.
Even before this amendment, the Constitution contained a provision for free and compulsory
education for children under Article
45 in Part IV. However, being a directive principle, it was not enforceable by the courts. Now,
there is scope for judicial intervention in this regard.
This amendment changed the subject matter of Article 45 in directive principles. It now
reads-'The state shall endeavour to provide early childhood care and education for all children
until they complete the age of six years.’ It also added a new fundamental duty under Article 51A
that reads-'It shall be the duty of every citizen of India to
provide opportunities for education to his child or ward between the age of six and fourteen
years’.
In 1993 itself, the Supreme Court recognised a Fundamental Right to primary education in the right
to life under Article 21. It held that every child or citizen of this country has a right to free
education until he completes the age of 14 years. Thereafter, his right to education is subject to
the limits of economic capacity and development of the state. In this judgement, the Court
overruled its earlier judgement (1992) which declared that there was a fundamental right to
education up to any level including professional education like medicine and engineering.
In pursuance of Article 21A, the Parliament enacted the Right of Children to Free and
Compulsory Education (RTE) Act, 2OO9. This Act seeks to provide that every child has a right to be
provided full time elementary education of satisfactory and equitable quality in a formal school
which satisfies certain essential norms and standards. This legislation is anchored in the belief
that the values of equality, social justice and democracy and the creation of a just and humane
society can be achieved only through provision of inclusive elementary education to all.¹²ᵃ
5. Protection Against Arrest and Detention
Article 22 grants protection to persons who are arrested or detained. Detention is of two types,
namely, punitive and preventive. Punitive detention is to punish a person for an offence committed
by him after trial and conviction in a court. Preventive detention, on the other hand, means
detention of a person without trial and conviction by a court. Its purpose is not to punish a
person for a past offence but to prevent him from committing an offence in the near future. Thus,
preventive detention is only a precautionary measure and based on suspicion.
The Article 22 has two parts-the first part deals with the cases of ordinary law and the second
part deals with the cases of preventive detention law.
(a) The first part of Article 22 confers the following rights on a person who is arrested or
detained under an ordinary law:
(i) Right to be informed of the grounds of arrest.
(ii) Right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner.
(iii) Right to be produced before a magistrate within 24 hou including the journey time.
(iv) Right to be released after 24 hours unless the magistr authorises further detention.
These safeguards are not available to an enemy alien or a person arrested or detained under a
preventive detention law.
The Supreme Court also ruled that the arrest and detention in the first part of Article 22 do not
cover arrest under the orders of a court, civil arrest, arrest on failure to pay the income tax,
and deportation of an alien. They apply only to an act of a criminal or quasi-criminal nature or
some activity prejudicial to public interest.
(b) The second part of Article 22 grants protection to persons who are arrested or detained under a
preventive detention law. This protection is available to both citizens as well as aliens and
includes the following:
(i) The detention of a person cannot exceed three months unless advisory board reports sufficient
cause for extended detentio The board is to consist of judges of a high court.
(ii) The grounds of detention should be communicated to the deten However, the facts considered to
be against the public inter need not be disclosed.
(iii) The detenu should be afforded an opportunity to make representation against the
detention order.
Article 22 also authorises the Parliament to prescribe (a) the circumstances and the classes of
cases in which a person can be detained for more than three months under a preventive detention law
without obtaining the opinion of an advisory board; (b) the maximum period for which a person can
be detained in any classes of cases under a preventive detention law; and (c) the procedure to be
followed by an advisory board in an inquiry.
The 44th Amendment Act of 1978 has reduced the period of detention without obtaining the opinion of
an advisory board from three to two months. However, this provision has not yet been brought into
force, hence, the original period of three months still continues.
The Constitution has divided the legislative power with regard to preventive detention between
the Parliament and the state legislatures. The Parliament has exclusive authority to make a law
of preventive detention for reasons connected with defence, foreign affairs and the security of
India. Both the Parliament as well as the state legislatures can concurrently make a law of
preventive detention for reasons connected with the security of a state, the maintenance of
public order and the maintenance of supplies and services essential to the community.
The preventive detention laws made by the Parliament are:
(a) Preventive Detention Act, 195O. Expired in 1969.
(b) Maintenance of Internal Security Act (MISA), 1971. Repealed in 1978.
(c) Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act (COFEPOSA), 1974.
(d) National Security Act (NASA), 198O.
(e) Prevention of Blackmarketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act
(PBMSECA), 198O.
(f) Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act (TADA), 1985. Repealed in 1995.
(g) Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (PITNDPSA),
1988.
(h) Prevention of Terrorism Act (POTA), 2OO2. Repealed in 2OO4.
(i) Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), 1967, as amended in 2OO4, 2OO8, 2O12 and 2O19.
It is unfortunate to know that no democratic country in the world has made preventive detention as
an integral part of the Constitution as has been done in India. It is unknown in USA. It was
resorted to in Britain only during first and second world war time. In India, preventive detention
existed even during the British rule. For example, the Bengal State Prisoners Regulation of 1818
and the Defence of India Act of 1939 provided for preventive detention.
Comments
Post a Comment